• The Waqf Act, 1954 - Waqf has only been strengthened post-independence. The Waqf Act of 1954 passed provided a pathway toward the centralisation of Waqfs. Central Waqf Council of India, a statutory body was established in 1964 by the Government of India under this Waqf Act of 1954. This central body oversees the work under various state Waqf boards which were established under provisions of Section 9(1) of the Waqf Act, 1954.
• The Waqf Act, 1995 - The Waqf Act was made even more favourable to Muslims in 1995, which made it an overriding law. The Waqf Act, 1995 was enacted to govern the administration of Waqf Properties (Religious Endowments) in India. It provides for the power and functions of the Waqf Council, the State Waqf Boards, and the Chief Executive Officer, and also the duties of mutawalli. This Act also describes the power and restrictions of a Waqf Tribunal that acts in lieu of a civil court under its jurisdiction. The Waqf Tribunals are deemed to be a civil court and required to exercise all the powers and functions exercised by a civil court under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The decision of a Tribunal shall be final and binding on the parties. No suit or legal proceedings shall lie under any civil court. Thus, making the Waqf Tribunal decisions above any civil court.
• Amendments in 2013 - Some provisions of the Act were amended in the year 2013 to make waqf management more efficient and transparent. However, during the course of implementation of the Act, it was felt that the Act did not prove effective in improving administration of Waqf.
• The Waqf Repeal Bill, 2022 - For the purpose of achieving a more equitable arrangement and treatment of bodies such as waqf and other recognized religious entities established under similar intent, the aforesaid Waqf Act, 1995 as amended was tabled in Rajya Sabha on December 8, 2023.

1. Establishment of Wakf Boards:
   • The Act provides for the establishment of Central Wakf Council and State Wakf Boards to oversee the management of Wakf properties.
   • The Central Wakf Council advises the Central Government on matters related to Wakf properties, while State Wakf Boards manage Wakf properties at the state level.
2. Survey of Wakf Properties:
   • The Act mandates the survey and registration of all Wakf properties to maintain a comprehensive record.
3. Prevention of Encroachment:
   • The Act provides legal mechanisms to prevent encroachment and misuse of Wakf properties.
4. Management of Wakf Properties:
   • Wakf Boards are empowered to lease, develop, and manage Wakf properties for the benefit of the community.
5. Legal Framework:
   • The Act provides for the resolution of disputes related to Wakf properties through Wakf Tribunals.

1. Strengthening Legal Framework:
   • Introducing stricter penalties for encroachment and misuse of Wakf properties.
   • Enhancing the powers of Wakf Boards to take action against illegal occupants.
2. Transparency and Accountability:
   • Mandating regular audits of Wakf properties and finances.
   • Ensuring greater transparency in the leasing and development of Wakf properties.
3. Utilization of Wakf Properties:
   • Promoting the use of Wakf properties for educational, healthcare, and community welfare initiatives.
   • Encouraging public-private partnerships for the development of Wakf properties.
4. Digitalization:
   • Creating a centralized digital database of all Wakf properties to improve monitoring and management.
5. Empowerment of Wakf Boards:
   • Providing more autonomy and resources to State Wakf Boards for effective management.

• Example of Encroachment: In Delhi, a 2019 National Commission for Minorities report revealed that over 50% of Wakf properties, including mosques and graveyards, were illegally occupied by private builders or encroachers. For instance, a Wakf-owned plot in Okhla was converted into a commercial complex due to weak oversight.
• Example of Mismanagement: In Uttar Pradesh, a Wakf property in Lucknow, valued at crores, was sold off in 2018 by a local mutawalli (custodian) without proper authorization, depriving the community of funds meant for orphanages.

1. Renaming the Waqf Act, 1995: The Act has been renamed to the Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency, and Development Act, 1995, to reflect its broader objective of improving the management and efficiency of Waqf boards and properties, emphasising empowerment and development along with effective administration.
2. 2. Formation of Waqf: The Act allows waqf to be formed by: (i) declaration, (ii) recognition based on long-term use (waqf by user), or (iii) endowment when the line of succession ends (waqf-alal-aulad).

• representatives of Muslim organisations,
• scholars in Islamic law, and
• chairpersons of Waqf Boards.

• Resistance from Wakf Boards: In 2024, some Wakf Board officials opposed the bill, fearing loss of autonomy, similar to how state governments resisted GST in 2017 over revenue concerns. For example, the Kerala Wakf Board argued that external members might not understand religious nuances.
• Implementation Issues: Without resources, reforms could falter. For instance, the Swachh Bharat Mission succeeded due to dedicated funding, while the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam lagged due to logistical gaps—surveying Wakf properties nationwide could face similar risks.

1. Encroachment of Wakf Properties:
   • One of the biggest challenges faced by Wakf Boards is the encroachment of Wakf lands. For example:
     • In Delhi, several Wakf properties have been encroached upon by individuals and organizations. The Delhi High Court has repeatedly directed the Delhi Wakf Board to take action against encroachers.
     • In Telangana, the State Wakf Board has identified over 1,000 acres of Wakf land under encroachment, including by government agencies.
2. Mismanagement and Corruption:
   • There have been allegations of mismanagement and corruption in the administration of Wakf properties. For instance:
     • In Maharashtra, the State Wakf Board was accused of leasing out prime Wakf properties at throwaway prices to private parties.
     • In Uttar Pradesh, the State Wakf Board faced criticism for failing to utilize Wakf properties for community welfare.
3. Judicial Interventions:
   • The Supreme Court and various High Courts have intervened to protect Wakf properties. For example:
     • In 2022, the Supreme Court directed the Telangana State Wakf Board to take possession of a 1,600-acre Wakf land in Hyderabad that was under illegal occupation.
     • In 2021, the Delhi High Court ordered the removal of encroachments from a Wakf property in Mehrauli, Delhi.
4. Utilization of Wakf Properties:
   • Several State Wakf Boards have initiated projects to utilize Wakf properties for community welfare. For example:
     • In Karnataka, the State Wakf Board has developed educational institutions and hospitals on Wakf lands.
     • In Tamil Nadu, the State Wakf Board has leased out Wakf properties for the construction of shopping complexes and community halls.
5. Digitalization of Wakf Records:
   • The Central Wakf Council has initiated the digitalization of Wakf records to improve transparency and accountability. For example:
     • In 2023, the Telangana State Wakf Board launched a mobile app to provide information about Wakf properties and report encroachments.

1. Overview:
   • Bihar has a large number of Wakf properties, including mosques, dargahs, graveyards, and educational institutions.
   • These properties are managed by the Bihar State Sunni Wakf Board, which oversees their administration and utilization.
2. Phulwari Sharif Wakf Estate:
   • The Phulwari Sharif Wakf Estate is one of the most prominent Wakf properties in Bihar.
   • Located in Phulwari Sharif, a suburb of Patna, this estate includes mosques, madrasas, and other charitable institutions.
   • The estate plays a significant role in supporting Islamic education through its madrasas, which provide religious and secular education to students.
3. Other Notable Wakf Properties:
   • Khanqah Mujibia (Phulwari Sharif): A historic Sufi shrine and educational center.
   • Bihar Sharif Wakf Estate: Includes mosques, madrasas, and charitable institutions.
   • Sultanganj Wakf Estate: Known for its religious and educational activities.

1. Encroachment:
   • Like other states, Bihar faces the issue of encroachment on Wakf properties. Illegal occupation of Wakf lands by individuals and organizations is a major challenge.
2. Mismanagement:
   • There have been allegations of mismanagement and lack of transparency in the administration of Wakf properties by the Bihar State Sunni Wakf Board.
3. Underutilization:
   • Many Wakf properties in Bihar are underutilized and not fully developed for educational or community welfare purposes.
4. Lack of Funds:
   • The Bihar State Sunni Wakf Board often faces a shortage of funds for the maintenance and development of Wakf properties.

1. Strengthening Legal Framework:
   • Introduce stricter penalties for encroachment and misuse of Wakf properties.
   • Enhance the powers of the Bihar State Sunni Wakf Board to take action against illegal occupants.
2. Transparency and Accountability:
   • Conduct regular audits of Wakf properties and finances to ensure transparency.
   • Implement digitalization of Wakf records to improve monitoring and management.
3. Utilization for Education:
   • Develop Wakf properties into educational hubs by establishing schools, colleges, and vocational training centers.
   • Upgrade existing madrasas to provide both religious and modern education, aligning with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020.
4. Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs):
   • Encourage public-private partnerships for the development of Wakf properties.
   • Lease out Wakf lands for the construction of shopping complexes, hospitals, and community centers, with a portion of the revenue used for community welfare.
5. Community Welfare Initiatives:
   • Utilize Wakf properties for healthcare initiatives, such as setting up clinics and hospitals.
   • Establish skill development centers to provide vocational training to the youth.

1. Madrasas Supported by Wakf Properties:
   • Many Wakf properties in Bihar, such as the Phulwari Sharif Wakf Estate, support madrasas that provide religious and secular education.
   • These madrasas play a crucial role in educating underprivileged children, especially from the Muslim community.
2. Potential for Modern Education:
   • With proper reforms, Wakf properties can be developed into centers of modern education, offering courses in science, technology, and vocational skills.
   • This aligns with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, which emphasizes the integration of modern and traditional education.
3. Scholarships and Financial Aid:
   • Revenue generated from Wakf properties can be used to provide scholarships and financial aid to students from marginalized communities.

Mission Karmayogi

Introduction

In the dynamic landscape of public administration, the development and empowerment of civil servants have become a critical element in ensuring the effective delivery of government services and the successful implementation of policies. Mission Karmayogi (2 September 2020), a landmark initiative by the Indian government, aims to address this imperative through a comprehensive capacity-building program. This notes given by Bihar Naman GS, examines the potential impact of Mission Karmayogi on the capacity-building of civil servants, drawing insights from relevant literature and exploring the challenges and opportunities presented by this initiative.

The significance of capacity building for civil servants cannot be overstated, as it directly impacts the quality of public service delivery and the ability of government agencies to effectively address the evolving needs of citizens. Effective governance relies on the competencies, ethics, and efficiency of civil servants, making capacity-building a cornerstone for national development.

Core Tenets of Mission Karmayogi

The essence of Mission Karmayogi lies in the word “Karmayogi,” which signifies a worker dedicated to their duties with commitment and ethics. The initiative focuses on:

• Capacity Building: Providing civil servants with opportunities for lifelong learning and continuous professional development.
• Competency-Driven Approach: Equipping officers with role-specific competencies to enhance efficiency and productivity.
• Technological Integration: Utilizing advanced digital platforms to offer accessible, affordable, and adaptive learning.

Launched in September 2, 2020, Mission Karmayogi aims to enhance the efficiency, effectiveness, and accountability of India's civil services by embracing modern methods while maintaining Indian ethos. It promotes transparency and accountability through RTI, Citizen Charters, E-Governance, and grievance redressal systems, which are key to good governance. The program focuses on building the skills of civil servants to make them more creative, proactive, and tech-savvy, preparing them for future challenges.

With an allocation of over ₹510 crore, the initiative targets 46 lakh central employees over five years (2020-2025). It seeks to eliminate elitism and ensure equitable opportunities for skill development across all levels of government employees.

Key Features of Mission Karmayogi

• Breaking Bureaucratic Silos: The initiative aims to eliminate the silo mentality across ministries and departments, fostering cross-functional collaboration.
• 70-20-10 Learning Model: This model ensures 70% of learning from on-the-job experiences, 20% from interactions with peers and mentors, and 10% from formal training.
• Fair and Transparent Evaluations: Objective assessments will measure civil servant performance to ensure accountability and effectiveness.

Six key pillars of Mission Karmyogi

Mission Karmayogi is built on six key pillars that form the foundation for a comprehensive capacity-building initiative for India's civil services. These pillars ensure a structured, technology-driven, and competency-based approach to governance.

1. Policy Framework

This pillar establishes the guiding principles, rules, and governance structures for implementing Mission Karmayogi. It includes:

• Defining competency-based training models for civil servants.
• Aligning training with national priorities and governance needs.
• Ensuring institutional coordination across ministries, departments, and training academies.

2. Institutional Framework

A structured institutional setup is essential for managing, delivering, and monitoring training programs. Key institutions involved include:

• Capacity Building Commission (CBC): Oversees competency development and evaluates training programs.
• Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) - Karmayogi Bharat: Manages the iGOT (Integrated Government Online Training) platform.
• Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT): Plays a central role in policy formulation and execution.

3. Competency-Based Learning

Mission Karmayogi shifts from rule-based to role-based training, focusing on competency enhancement rather than just seniority. It includes:

• Behavioral, functional, and domain-specific training tailored to roles.
• Continuous learning opportunities rather than one-time training sessions.
• Flexibility in learning paths for different levels of government employees.

4. Digital Learning through iGOT Platform

The iGOT (Integrated Government Online Training) Karmayogi platform is the backbone of the initiative, providing:

• Personalized learning experiences using AI-driven course recommendations.
• On-demand digital training modules accessible to all civil servants.
• Data-driven tracking of learning progress and performance.

5. Monitoring and Evaluation Framework

To measure the effectiveness of training programs, Mission Karmayogi includes:

• Real-time data analytics to assess participation and progress.
• Impact assessment studies to evaluate improvements in governance.
• Feedback mechanisms for continuous course refinement.

6. Human Resource Management Reforms

Mission Karmayogi aims to transform HR policies in government by:

• Linking training with career progression and performance appraisals.
• Encouraging a culture of continuous learning and professional development.
• Strengthening the role of leadership and ethics in governance.

The iGOT Initiative under Mission Karmayogi

The Integrated Government Online Training (iGOT) platform forms the backbone of Mission Karmayogi. With the motto “Competent Civil Services for Good Governance,” iGOT is designed to overcome the limitations of traditional training mechanisms.

Features of iGOT

• Module-based online training programs accessible on-site and on a flexitime basis.
• A repository of resources available as Massive Online Open Courses (MOOCs).
• Certification-based learning paths to ensure measurable outcomes.
• Ensures that even grassroots-level government servants can participate in training programs, bridging the gap between central, state, and local governance frameworks.

Objectives of Mission Karmayogi

Mission Karmayogi is guided by the principles laid out in the National Training Policy-2012, which envisions equipping civil servants with the competencies required for their current and future roles.

• Reorienting Civil Services Training: Shifting focus from sporadic training events to continuous learning.
• Inclusive Capacity Building: Expanding the training outreach to include a larger segment of government employees, particularly at the state and UT levels.
• Overcoming Current Challenges: Addressing issues such as limited access to training resources and a fragmented training ecosystem.

Significance of Mission Karmayogi

• Reimagining the Civil Servant: Mission Karmayogi aspires to transform civil servants into ideal “Karmayogis,” embodying creativity, innovation, and commitment to public service.
• Strengthening Governance: The program ensures continuous capacity building, enabling government servants to remain aligned with modern governance challenges and public expectations.
• Enhancing Professionalism: By fostering a professional and progressive work culture, Mission Karmayogi aids in creating an efficient and responsive administrative system.
• Eliminating Silos: The mission aims to integrate diverse training efforts under a unified framework, ensuring coherence and eliminating redundancies in the training curriculum.
• Promoting Technology: A technology-enabled approach helps in real-time monitoring, evaluation, and upskilling of the workforce, aligning with the vision of a “New India.”

Capacity Building Commission

A key component of the National Programme for Civil Services Capacity Building (NPCSCB), the Commission is responsible for guiding and regulating training programs to enhance governance efficiency. It consists of a Chairperson and two Members, supported by a Secretariat.

Challenges in Implementing Mission Karmayogi

While Mission Karmayogi aims to modernize India’s civil services, several challenges must be addressed for effective implementation. These challenges range from cultural resistance to infrastructural and systemic barriers.

1. Resistance to Change

One of the biggest challenges in implementing Mission Karmayogi is overcoming bureaucratic inertia and skepticism.

• Traditional Mindset: Many government officials are accustomed to conventional working methods and may view digital training as unnecessary or burdensome.
• Fear of Role Alterations: Some employees may resist training programs due to concerns about shifting job responsibilities, skill redundancy, or increased workload.
• Lack of Immediate Tangible Benefits: Unlike conventional promotions or pay raises, skill enhancement through training does not always provide immediate career rewards, making it harder to incentivize participation.
• Change Management Gaps: A structured change management strategy is required to align employees with the vision of Mission Karmayogi.

2. Resource Constraints

Mission Karmayogi’s success depends on adequate funding, infrastructure, and human resources.

• Financial Challenges: A nationwide digital training ecosystem requires substantial investments in IT infrastructure, content development, and personnel.
• Infrastructure Deficiencies: Many government offices, especially at district and sub-district levels, lack the necessary technological infrastructure, such as high-speed internet and modern computing devices, to support digital learning.
• Lack of Skilled Trainers: Building a qualified pool of trainers for online and offline modules is a slow and resource-intensive process.

3. Political Interference

Political influence in bureaucratic operations could pose hurdles to impartial and merit-based reforms.

• Risk of Bias in Training Content: Training programs must be politically neutral, but there is a possibility that curriculum design could be influenced by ruling political ideologies.
• Frequent Policy Shifts: Administrative priorities often change with political transitions, which may disrupt the continuity of Mission Karmayogi’s long-term vision.
• Influence on Performance Assessments: If linked to career progression, training evaluations might be subject to favoritism or political favoritism rather than merit-based assessments.

4. Corruption and Nepotism

While Mission Karmayogi aims to promote efficiency and accountability, it may also inadvertently create loopholes if robust monitoring mechanisms are not in place.

• Manipulation of Learning Assessments: If performance in training modules influences promotions, there is a risk of falsified records or undue influence to manipulate results.
• Nepotistic Training Access: There could be a tendency to selectively offer premium training opportunities to certain groups, limiting equal opportunities for all government employees.
• Lack of Transparent Review Systems: Without strong oversight, some bureaucrats may bypass training requirements while still advancing in their careers.

5. Technological Barriers

Many civil servants, particularly those who have spent decades in traditional roles, may struggle with digital learning platforms.

• Digital Literacy Gaps: Not all employees are familiar with online training methods, and a lack of digital skills can slow adoption.
• Resistance to Technology-Driven Learning: Older employees may find self-paced e-learning platforms difficult to navigate and prefer conventional classroom settings.
• Cybersecurity Concerns: A large-scale digital learning platform requires robust cybersecurity to protect sensitive government training data from breaches or cyberattacks.

6. Limited Accessibility

There is a risk that Mission Karmayogi’s benefits will remain concentrated among senior officials, leaving out a significant portion of the workforce.

• Exclusion of Lower Cadre Employees: Training programs often prioritize officers in higher ranks, while support staff, contractual employees, and lower-cadre officials may have limited access to capacity-building programs.
• Language and Content Barriers: Training content is often developed in English or Hindi, making it difficult for employees from non-Hindi-speaking states to engage effectively.
• Lack of Offline Training Alternatives: Employees who lack access to digital devices or internet connectivity may be left behind if physical training alternatives are not available.

7. Fragmentation

The presence of multiple institutions offering uncoordinated training programs leads to inefficiencies and a lack of standardization.

• Overlapping Courses: Different government training institutions may offer similar courses without synchronization, leading to redundancy and resource wastage.
• Lack of Unified Learning Framework: Without a standardized approach, employees might receive inconsistent training experiences across different departments.
• Challenges in Evaluation and Impact Measurement: Dispersed training programs make it difficult to assess the overall effectiveness of Mission Karmayogi in improving administrative capabilities.

8. Geographical Challenges

Government employees in remote and rural areas often face significant obstacles in accessing quality training programs.

• Limited Internet Connectivity: Many rural areas in India still suffer from poor internet penetration, making it difficult for officials to access online training modules.
• Lack of Physical Training Centers: Remote areas often do not have well-equipped training institutes, forcing employees to travel long distances for in-person learning.
• Time Constraints for Field Officials: Government employees in remote regions, such as police personnel, health workers, and revenue officers, have demanding jobs that leave little time for training participation.

Opportunities for Enhancing Capacity Building

To ensure that Mission Karmayogi achieves its full potential, capacity-building efforts must be dynamic, future-oriented, and inclusive. The following opportunities can significantly enhance the initiative's impact:

1. Leveraging AI and Data Analytics

The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and data analytics into training programs can transform the learning experience for government employees.

• Personalized Learning Paths: AI-driven recommendation engines can curate customized training modules based on an individual's learning progress, role, and responsibilities.
• Real-Time Performance Analytics: Data analytics can track employee progress, assess knowledge retention, and provide insights for improving course effectiveness.
• AI-Powered Chatbots and Virtual Assistants: These can provide instant guidance, answer queries, and assist employees in navigating training modules.
• Predictive Analytics for Workforce Planning: AI can help identify skill gaps across departments and recommend targeted training programs.
• Automated Assessments and Certifications: AI-driven evaluation tools can streamline competency testing and certification processes.

2. Global Best Practices

Learning from international experiences can strengthen India's approach to capacity building. Key lessons can be drawn from:

• Singapore’s Civil Service College (CSC): A model for lifelong learning, leadership training, and digital governance skills.
• Estonia’s e-Governance Academy: Best known for its digital governance training, Estonia offers insights into secure, transparent, and efficient e-governance practices.
• UK’s National Leadership Centre: Focuses on cross-government leadership development and strategic decision-making.
• South Korea’s AI-Based Training Models: Demonstrates how AI and automation can improve public sector upskilling.
• Nordic Countries’ Citizen-Centric Governance: Lessons in promoting participatory governance and responsive service delivery.

By adapting these global best practices to India’s unique administrative and socio-cultural context, capacity-building efforts can be significantly strengthened.

3. Public Service Leadership Development

Strong leadership is crucial for effective governance. Establishing a National Leadership Academy can:

• Develop strategic decision-making skills among civil servants through case studies, simulations, and mentoring.
• Promote interdepartmental collaboration by encouraging knowledge exchange among officers from different ministries and states.
• Foster crisis management capabilities, preparing officials to respond effectively to emergencies and unforeseen challenges.
• Encourage ethical leadership, instilling values of integrity, transparency, and citizen-centric governance.
• Introduce mentorship programs, where experienced officers guide younger bureaucrats in navigating administrative complexities.

4. Adaptive Governance

As governance challenges evolve, India’s administrative framework must embrace agility, innovation, and responsiveness. To enable this:

• Agile Policy Training: Officials should be trained to adapt quickly to changing socio-economic and technological landscapes.
• Encouraging Experimentation and Pilot Programs: Promoting small-scale policy trials before large-scale implementation to minimize risks.
• Interdisciplinary Learning: Training programs should integrate knowledge from fields like behavioral economics, technology, and sustainability to improve policymaking.
• Citizen Engagement Training: Officials should be trained to incorporate citizen feedback into governance decisions, making policies more inclusive.
• Cross-Sector Collaboration: Training modules should promote partnerships between the government, private sector, and civil society to drive innovation in public administration.

Way Forward for Mission Karmayogi

Mission Karmayogi has the potential to revolutionize India's bureaucratic framework by fostering a culture of continuous learning, efficiency, and citizen-centric governance. To maximize its impact, the following key measures should be adopted:

1. Effective Implementation

A well-defined and structured implementation plan is essential for the success of the iGOT (Integrated Government Online Training) platform. This should include:

• A phased rollout strategy, prioritizing departments based on critical needs.
• Standardized content development across ministries to ensure consistency and relevance.
• Mandatory participation frameworks to encourage widespread adoption.
• Technical support and infrastructure development, ensuring seamless accessibility to the platform, particularly in remote areas.

2. Capacity Building for Trainers

Trainers play a crucial role in the success of any learning initiative. To enhance their effectiveness:

• A certification process should be introduced to qualify trainers for online and offline modules.
• Regular Train-the-Trainer programs should be conducted to keep them updated on new developments.
• Trainers should be provided with AI-driven analytics tools to track learner progress and personalize training approaches.
• Establishment of regional training hubs to facilitate in-person learning where necessary.

3. Incentivizing Learning

To drive engagement and motivation among government employees:

• Integration with performance appraisals should be established, linking training completion with career progression, promotions, and rewards.
• Gamification techniques such as leaderboards, badges, and certifications can be introduced to make learning engaging.
• Monetary or non-monetary incentives, such as recognition programs and award schemes, can be implemented for top performers.
• Encouragement of peer learning communities, where employees can share knowledge and best practices.

4. Continuous Monitoring and Feedback

To ensure that Mission Karmayogi remains effective and relevant:

• A real-time analytics dashboard should be developed to track course completion rates, learning patterns, and effectiveness.
• Surveys and feedback mechanisms should be introduced to gather insights from participants regarding course content and delivery.
• Annual impact assessment studies should be conducted to measure how the training is translating into improved governance and service delivery.
• A dedicated advisory body should periodically review and update training modules based on emerging governance challenges and best practices.

5. Inclusivity in Training

For Mission Karmayogi to achieve holistic administrative transformation, inclusivity is key:

• Training modules should cater to all levels of government employees, including Group A, B, C, and even contractual or support staff.
• Content should be made available in multiple regional languages to ensure accessibility across diverse linguistic backgrounds.
• Special training provisions should be introduced for women employees, differently-abled staff, and those from marginalized communities to promote equitable learning opportunities.
• Offline learning opportunities should be provided for those with limited digital access, ensuring that no one is left behind.

Mission Karmyogi and Bihar

Mission Karmayogi, the Government of India's initiative to enhance the capabilities of civil servants, has seen significant implementation in Bihar. A notable development occurred on October 7, 2024, when a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) was signed between the Capacity Building Commission (CBC), Karmayogi Bharat (Special Purpose Vehicle), and the Bihar Institute of Public Administration and Rural Development (BIPARD). This collaboration aims to transition public servants from a rule-based to a role-based approach, enhancing their skills through the iGOT Karmayogi digital platform.

Following this agreement, Bihar has made substantial progress:

• Onboarding of Officials: Over 2.4 lakh government officials in Bihar have been registered on the iGOT Karmayogi platform, reflecting the state's commitment to comprehensive capacity building.
• Course Engagement: These officials have actively participated in various online courses available on the platform. To date, there have been 31,368 course enrollments, with 23,724 courses successfully completed and certificates issued.
• Language Accessibility: To ensure inclusivity, BIPARD has adapted 25 course modules into Hindi, complete with voice-overs and subtitles, making the content more accessible to a broader audience.

This strategic implementation of Mission Karmayogi in Bihar exemplifies the state's dedication to fostering a skilled and efficient civil service, poised to meet evolving governance challenges.

Conclusion 

Mission Karmayogi marks a transformative shift in India’s civil services, aiming to create an accountable, transparent, and efficient bureaucracy. By embracing digital tools, competency-based training, and leadership development, it enhances public service delivery. 

To ensure success, overcoming bureaucratic inertia, securing financial support, and fostering continuous learning are crucial. Integrating global best practices and AI-driven learning models can make Mission Karmayogi a global benchmark for civil service reforms. 

With sustained efforts and stakeholder collaboration, India’s civil services can become adaptive, innovative, and citizen-centric, driving national progress toward sustainable development and good governance.

In today’s world, where appearances often take precedence over reality, people tend to indulge in show-offs beyond their means. The proverb "Chari Aana Ke Jamera, Choudah Aana Ke Machan" perfectly illustrates this mindset. It signifies a situation where someone with limited resources tries to create an extravagant image, ultimately leading to financial and personal difficulties. This behavior is commonly seen in modern society, where individuals, businesses, and even politicians attempt to present themselves as more influential or successful than they actually are, only to face repercussions later.

The trend of spending beyond one’s capacity is widespread, particularly in urban settings. Many people purchase expensive clothes, gadgets, and cars, even if it means taking loans or exhausting their savings. Social media has further fueled this tendency, where individuals constantly showcase luxurious vacations, high-end purchases, and extravagant lifestyles, often hiding the financial burden behind it. The pressure to keep up with such a lifestyle forces many into unnecessary debt, creating long-term economic instability. Instead of prioritizing genuine financial well-being, people get trapped in the cycle of external validation.

This mindset is also prevalent in the business world. Many entrepreneurs, in an attempt to establish a strong market presence, invest heavily in lavish offices, high-end advertisements, and luxury perks, often overlooking the actual strength of their product or service. Such businesses might initially attract attention, but when financial crises hit, they struggle to sustain themselves. Instead of focusing on building a strong foundation, their obsession with grandeur leads to bankruptcy and loss of credibility. A similar scenario is observed in the startup ecosystem, where many companies burn cash excessively on marketing gimmicks rather than improving their business model. Eventually, they collapse under the weight of their own unsustainable spending.

Even in politics, this tendency is evident. During elections, candidates make extravagant promises to the public—free services, massive development projects, and large-scale employment opportunities—without considering the feasibility of these commitments. They organize grand rallies, flood media with expensive campaigns, and create an illusion of power and influence. However, when they come into power, they struggle to deliver on their promises due to budget constraints and administrative challenges. As a result, their credibility is questioned, and public dissatisfaction grows. The inability to balance aspirations with practicality leads to failure in governance, reinforcing the lesson that mere appearances cannot replace actual work.

The education sector is no exception. Many students and parents believe that only elite institutions guarantee success. As a result, students enroll in expensive colleges without considering their financial capacity. The burden of high fees often leads to student debt, which becomes difficult to repay. Similarly, some families stretch beyond their means to admit their children to prestigious schools, ignoring the stress it brings upon their financial stability. Instead of prioritizing quality education within a reasonable budget, they chase brand names, only to realize later that success depends on skills and hard work, not on fancy degrees.

In personal life, this proverb holds great relevance as well. Many individuals, in their attempt to gain social validation, throw lavish parties, buy luxury goods, and lead an extravagant lifestyle without assessing their actual financial condition. Initially, it may provide temporary happiness and admiration, but in the long run, it results in financial instability and mental stress. True respect and recognition come from one's actions, ethics, and contributions to society, not from material possessions or showy lifestyles. A person who understands this distinction is more likely to lead a peaceful and stable life.

The core lesson from this proverb is the importance of financial wisdom and practicality. Rather than focusing on external validation, individuals and organizations should prioritize long-term stability and sustainable growth. Spending within one’s limits not only ensures financial security but also brings mental peace. A simple, well-balanced life is far more rewarding than a hollow display of wealth.

In conclusion, "Chari Aana Ke Jamera, Choudah Aana Ke Machan" serves as a timeless reminder that reality should always take precedence over appearances. Whether in business, politics, education, or personal life, making decisions based on actual resources and capabilities is the key to long-term success. The world may tempt us to indulge in superficiality, but true wisdom lies in understanding our limits and focusing on genuine growth rather than fleeting displays of wealth.

 

Human nature has a tendency to desire more than what one already possesses. Sometimes, this desire becomes so intense that one forgets the value and importance of what they already have. In this context, the famous saying, "Halfway abandoned, chasing the whole, neither half remains, nor the whole is attained," holds profound meaning. It implies that when a person leaves behind their existing resources, achievements, or situation in pursuit of something greater, they not only lose what they already had but also fail to attain what they were chasing. This proverb teaches us that excessive greed and dissatisfaction ultimately lead to loss, and one must act with patience, contentment, and wisdom.

This proverb imparts a crucial life lesson: contentment and patience are the keys to success. When a person fails to appreciate what they already have and relentlessly pursues more, they often end up losing both. This saying applies not only to material wealth but also to education, career, relationships, business, and other important aspects of life.

The roots of this proverb lie deep in our society and folk culture. In a country like India, where contentment, restraint, and wisdom are considered essential life values, this proverb attempts to teach us that dissatisfaction and greed always lead to destruction. History is replete with examples of rulers and influential individuals who, in their quest for more, lost their empires, relationships, and wealth.

In the world of business, this proverb holds significant importance. Often, in their haste to earn greater profits, traders abandon their stable businesses to invest in uncertain ventures. If the new venture fails, not only does the new business collapse, but the old, established business is also lost.

For example, if an investor leaves a secure investment plan to invest in a more profitable but risky scheme, and the scheme fails, they lose their capital as well. This incident illustrates that decisions driven by greed and haste often prove detrimental.

This proverb also applies to the field of education and career. Many times, students start choosing another subject before mastering one, thinking that another field might be more profitable. However, due to this instability and impatience, they fail to gain expertise in any field, leading to an unsuccessful career.

Similarly, if a person leaves a stable and secure job in search of a higher-paying job and keeps changing jobs frequently, they might end up without any good job and lose their old job as well.

Human family and social life are also influenced by this proverb. Often, people neglect their old and trustworthy relationships in search of new and attractive ones. But when the new relationships turn out to be temporary and self-serving, they realize that they have lost their old, genuine relationships.

For example, in joint families, sometimes people separate from their families to live an independent life, but when they face difficulties, they realize that their old life was more secure and pleasant.

Sometimes, out of greed, a person makes decisions that later prove harmful. For instance, a person, driven by greed, might sell their land to buy more fertile land elsewhere, but if the new land does not meet their expectations, they lose both their old land and fail to benefit from the new one.

In conclusion, the proverb "Halfway abandoned, chasing the whole, neither half remains, nor the whole is attained" teaches us the importance of balance and correct priorities in life. It reminds us that patience, restraint, and dedication to our goals are essential for success. As Swami Vivekananda said, "Arise, awake, and do not stop until the goal is achieved."

Overall, this proverb imparts a very important life lesson. It teaches us to value our current achievements and possessions and not to rush in the desire for more. If we chase something without thinking, we might not only lose what we already have but also fail to attain what we were pursuing. Therefore, it is essential to act with contentment, patience, and wisdom in life. This is the real key to success. Let us draw inspiration from this proverb and remain dedicated to our goals so that we can achieve success.

 

Technology has become an inseparable part of modern life, reshaping how we interact, communicate, and perceive the world around us. Its influence extends beyond convenience and efficiency, deeply affecting our moral landscape and human relationships. In a diverse and rapidly developing country like India, and particularly in states like Bihar, the impact of technology is both transformative and complex. This essay explores how technology alters our moral values and interpersonal relationships, using examples from India and Bihar to illustrate these changes.

Technology introduces new ethical questions that challenge traditional moral frameworks. For instance, the rise of social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp has redefined privacy, accountability, and truth. In India, the spread of misinformation and fake news through these platforms has led to moral dilemmas about the responsibility of users and tech companies. During the COVID-19 pandemic, WhatsApp became a breeding ground for rumors about cures and vaccines, causing panic and mistrust. This raises questions: Should individuals be held morally accountable for sharing unverified information? What is the ethical responsibility of tech companies in curbing misinformation?

As the ancient Indian proverb goes, “Satyaṃ bruyat, priyaṃ bruyat, na bruyat satyam apriyam” (Speak the truth, speak it pleasantly, and do not speak the truth unpleasantly). This wisdom underscores the importance of truth and responsibility in communication, a principle that seems increasingly neglected in the age of viral misinformation.

In Bihar, where digital literacy is still evolving, the moral implications of technology are even more pronounced. For example, the misuse of smartphones to record and share private moments without consent has led to ethical concerns about privacy and dignity. The moral landscape is further complicated by the intersection of technology with deeply rooted cultural norms, such as gender roles. While technology empowers women in Bihar by providing access to education and employment opportunities, it also exposes them to online harassment, forcing society to confront new moral challenges.

Moreover, the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) and automation presents ethical questions about job displacement and human dignity. In Bihar, where agriculture and small-scale industries are the backbone of the economy, the introduction of AI-driven tools could lead to unemployment and economic inequality. This raises a moral question: Should technological progress be prioritized over the livelihoods of vulnerable communities? As Mahatma Gandhi once said, “The true measure of any society can be found in how it treats its most vulnerable members.” This principle reminds us to consider the human cost of technological advancement.

Technology has revolutionized human relationships, offering both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, it has bridged geographical distances, enabling people to stay connected with loved ones. For instance, migrant workers from Bihar, who often move to other states for work, rely on video calls and messaging apps to maintain relationships with their families. This has strengthened emotional bonds and provided a sense of continuity in their lives.

On the other hand, technology can also lead to emotional isolation and superficial relationships. In urban areas of India, the prevalence of smartphones has created a culture of constant connectivity, yet many people feel lonelier than ever. The phenomenon of "phubbing" (phone snubbing), where individuals prioritize their devices over face-to-face interactions, is becoming increasingly common. In Bihar, where community and family ties are traditionally strong, the intrusion of technology risks eroding these values. For example, young people spending excessive time on social media may neglect their responsibilities toward their families, leading to generational conflicts.

As the famous proverb goes, “A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.” This highlights the importance of balancing technological engagement with meaningful human connections.

Additionally, the commodification of relationships through dating apps and online platforms has altered the way people perceive love and companionship. In Bihar, where arranged marriages are still prevalent, the rise of dating apps like Tinder and Bumble has introduced a new dynamic to romantic relationships. While this provides young people with more choices, it also raises questions about the commodification of relationships and the erosion of traditional values.

As the poet Rumi once said, “The minute I heard my first love story, I started looking for you, not knowing how blind that was. Lovers don't finally meet somewhere. They're in each other all along.” This poetic insight reminds us that love is more than a transactional experience—it is a profound human connection.

Technology has the power to uplift marginalized communities, but it also exacerbates existing inequalities. In Bihar, one of India's poorest states, digital initiatives like the Digital India program have brought significant changes. For instance, the adoption of mobile banking and digital payment systems has empowered small businesses and farmers by providing access to financial services. This has not only improved economic conditions but also altered moral perceptions about trust and transparency in financial transactions.

However, the digital divide remains a pressing issue. While urban centers in India enjoy high-speed internet and advanced technologies, rural areas in Bihar often lack basic infrastructure. This disparity creates a moral dilemma: Should access to technology be considered a fundamental right? The unequal distribution of technological benefits raises questions about justice and fairness in society. As Dr. B.R. Ambedkar once said, “Justice has always evoked ideas of equality, of proportion of compensation.” This principle underscores the need to address the digital divide to ensure equitable access to technology.

Furthermore, the gig economy, driven by platforms like Uber, Swiggy, and Zomato, has created new employment opportunities but also raised concerns about worker rights and job security. In Bihar, where unemployment is a significant issue, many young people are turning to gig work as a source of income. However, the lack of labor protections and benefits in the gig economy poses ethical challenges, forcing society to rethink the balance between technological innovation and worker welfare.

Technology has also influenced cultural values, often creating a tension between tradition and modernity. In Bihar, where traditional practices and customs hold significant importance, the influx of technology has led to a cultural shift. For example, online matchmaking platforms have transformed the institution of marriage, offering young people more autonomy in choosing their partners. While this is a positive development, it also challenges traditional norms of arranged marriages, leading to moral debates about the preservation of cultural heritage.

Similarly, the popularity of streaming platforms like Netflix and YouTube has introduced global content to Bihar's youth, influencing their aspirations and lifestyles. While this exposure broadens horizons, it also raises concerns about the erosion of local culture and values. The moral question here is: How can societies balance the benefits of technological progress with the preservation of cultural identity?

As the saying goes, “A nation's culture resides in the hearts and in the soul of its people.” This reminds us of the importance of safeguarding cultural heritage in the face of globalization.

Moreover, the rise of digital entertainment has changed the way people consume media. In Bihar, where folk music and traditional performances are an integral part of the culture, the shift to digital platforms threatens the survival of these art forms. This raises ethical questions about the role of technology in preserving cultural heritage and promoting local talent.

As technology continues to evolve, the need for ethical responsibility becomes paramount. In India, the government has taken steps to regulate technology through laws like the Information Technology Act, but enforcement remains a challenge. In Bihar, grassroots initiatives to promote digital literacy and ethical use of technology are essential to address moral and social issues. For example, NGOs and educational institutions can play a crucial role in teaching young people about online safety, privacy, and the responsible use of social media.

Additionally, tech companies must be held accountable for the societal impact of their products. For instance, the design of algorithms that prioritize sensational content over factual information has contributed to the spread of misinformation. Ethical considerations should be integrated into the development and deployment of technology to ensure that it serves the greater good. As the philosopher Immanuel Kant famously said, “Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law.” This principle of universalizability can guide ethical decision-making in the tech industry.

Education plays a pivotal role in shaping how individuals and communities navigate the moral challenges posed by technology. In Bihar, where literacy rates are improving but still lag behind the national average, there is a pressing need for digital literacy programs. These programs should not only teach technical skills but also emphasize ethical behavior, critical thinking, and responsible use of technology.

For example, schools and colleges in Bihar can incorporate modules on digital ethics, covering topics such as cyberbullying, online privacy, and the impact of technology on mental health. By fostering a culture of awareness and responsibility, we can empower individuals to make informed decisions and navigate the complexities of the digital world. As the ancient Indian saying goes, “Vidya dadati vinayam” (Knowledge gives humility). This highlights the transformative power of education in shaping ethical behavior.

Technology is a double-edged sword, capable of both enriching and disrupting our moral landscape and human relationships. In India, and particularly in Bihar, its impact is profound, offering opportunities for progress while posing significant ethical challenges. As we navigate this digital age, it is crucial to foster a culture of responsibility, ensuring that technology serves as a tool for empowerment rather than a source of division. By addressing the moral dilemmas and social implications of technology, we can create a more equitable and connected society, where human relationships thrive in harmony with technological advancements.

Ultimately, the key lies in striking a balance between embracing technological innovation and preserving the values that define our humanity. Through collective efforts—by governments, tech companies, educators, and individuals—we can harness the potential of technology to build a better future for all. As the wise proverb reminds us, “The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is now.” Let us act now to shape a future where technology serves as a force for good, enriching our moral landscape and strengthening our human connections.

_{1. Democracy, Governance, and Politics}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“A nation's greatness is reflected in how it treats its weakest members.” – Mahatma Gandhi}
• _{“The essence of democracy is the willingness to cede power.” – Atal Bihari Vajpayee}
• _{“There is no meaning of democracy if the people are not well-informed.” – Dr. Rajendra Prasad}
• _{“Good governance is not fire-fighting but fire-prevention.” – Narendra Modi}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“A government for the people must depend on the intelligence, morality, and justice of the people.” – Grover Cleveland}
• _{“Democracy is not just the right to vote, it is the right to live in dignity.” – Naomi Klein}
• _{“The greatest threat to democracy is the indifference of its citizens.” – Aristotle}
• _{“The most important office in a democracy is the office of the citizen.” – Louis Brandeis}

_{2. Education and Knowledge}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Education should not be confined to schools. It should encompass all aspects of life.” – Rabindranath Tagore}
• _{“A pen is mightier than a sword, but only if it has been sharpened by knowledge.” – Dr. S. Radhakrishnan}
• _{“A learned man is respected everywhere.” – Chanakya}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“The mind is not a vessel to be filled, but a fire to be kindled.” – Plutarch}
• _{“The aim of education is the knowledge, not of facts, but of values.” – William S. Burroughs}
• _{“Education makes a people easy to lead, but difficult to drive; easy to govern, but impossible to enslave.” – Peter Brougham}

_{3. Economy, Growth, and Development}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“True development is not in wealth, but in the well-being of all.” – Vinoba Bhave}
• _{“A business that makes nothing but money is a poor business.” – J.R.D. Tata}
• _{“A just society is that society in which ascending sense of reverence and descending sense of contempt is dissolved into the creation of a compassionate society.” – B.R. Ambedkar}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“An economy that fails to serve the people ceases to have legitimacy.” – John Kenneth Galbraith}
• _{“Economic growth without social progress lets the great majority of people remain in poverty.” – John F. Kennedy}
• _{“The welfare of a nation can scarcely be inferred from a measure of national income.” – Simon Kuznets}

_{4. Social Justice and Equality}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“So long as you do not achieve social liberty, whatever freedom is provided by the law is of no avail to you.” – B.R. Ambedkar}
• _{“No one is free until we are all free.” – Savitribai Phule}
• _{“It is not enough to be compassionate; you must act.” – Mother Teresa}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“Justice delayed is justice denied.” – William E. Gladstone}
• _{“Prejudice is a burden that confuses the past, threatens the future, and renders the present inaccessible.” – Maya Angelou}
• _{“A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.” – Nelson Mandela}

_{5. Ethics, Morality, and Integrity}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Even if there is only one virtuous man in a village, he is enough to keep the entire village on the right path.” – Swami Vivekananda}
• _{“When wealth is lost, nothing is lost; when health is lost, something is lost; when character is lost, everything is lost.” – Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya}
• _{“Truth alone triumphs.” – Mundaka Upanishad}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” – Edmund Burke}
• _{“You cannot escape the responsibility of tomorrow by evading it today.” – Abraham Lincoln}
• _{“The greatness of a nation can be judged by how it treats its weakest members.” – Mahatma Gandhi}

_{6. Environment and Sustainability}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“When the last tree is cut, the last river poisoned, and the last fish dead, we will realize that we cannot eat money.” – Native American Proverb (quoted by Indian environmentalists)}
• _{“Nature has enough to fulfill everyone’s needs, but not enough for even one person’s greed.” – Mahatma Gandhi}
• _{“A river is more than an amenity, it is a treasure.” – Sunita Narain}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“We do not inherit the Earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.” – Native American Proverb}
• _{“The environment is where we all meet; where we all have a mutual interest.” – Lady Bird Johnson}
• _{“Look deep into nature, and then you will understand everything better.” – Albert Einstein}

_{7. Science, Technology, and Innovation}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Let us sacrifice our today so that our children can have a better tomorrow.” – A.P.J. Abdul Kalam}
• _{“The true laboratory is the mind, where behind illusions we uncover the laws of truth.” – Jagadish Chandra Bose}
• _{“Research is creating new knowledge.” – C.V. Raman}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“It is not the strongest species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but the ones most responsive to change.” – Charles Darwin}
• _{“Innovation is seeing what everybody has seen and thinking what nobody has thought.” – Albert Szent-Györgyi}
• _{“Technology will never replace great teachers, but technology in the hands of great teachers can be transformational.” – George Couros}

_{8. Nationalism and Patriotism}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“The preservation of freedom is not the task of soldiers alone. The whole nation has to be strong.” – Lal Bahadur Shastri}
• _{“Jai Jawan, Jai Kisan.” – Lal Bahadur Shastri}
• _{“A country’s greatness lies in its undying ideals of love and sacrifice that inspire the mothers of the race.” – Sarojini Naidu}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“A nation is not conquered until the hearts of its women are on the ground.” – Cheyenne Proverb}
• _{“True patriotism hates injustice in its own land more than anywhere else.” – Clarence Darrow}
• _{“The duty of a patriot is to protect his country from its government.” – Thomas Paine}

_{9. Women Empowerment}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Climbing to the top demands strength, whether it is to the top of Mount Everest or to the top of your career.” – Bachendri Pal}
• _{“The day a woman can walk freely at midnight on the roads, that day we can say India has achieved independence.” – Mahatma Gandhi}
• _{“You can tell the condition of a nation by looking at the status of its women.” – Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“The best protection any woman can have is courage.” – Elizabeth Cady Stanton}
• _{“Women, like men, should try to do the impossible. And when they fail, their failure should be a challenge to others.” – Amelia Earhart}
• _{“There is no tool for development more effective than the empowerment of women.” – Kofi Annan}

_{Quotes on Women Empowerment from Indian and Western thinkers across different themes to strengthen your UPSC, UPPSC, and BPSC mains essays.}

_{1. Women and Strength}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“A woman is the full circle. Within her is the power to create, nurture, and transform.” – Diane Mariechild}
• _{“A woman’s strength is not just in her resilience but in her ability to uplift others.” – Kiran Bedi}
• _{“The strength of a woman is not measured by the hardships she faces, but by the courage with which she overcomes them.” – Indira Nooyi}
• _{“Women should not depend on men for their strength. They should empower themselves through education and knowledge.” – Sarojini Naidu}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“A strong woman looks a challenge in the eye and gives it a wink.” – Gina Carey}
• _{“A woman is like a tea bag—you never know how strong she is until she gets in hot water.” – Eleanor Roosevelt}
• _{“There is no force equal to a woman determined to rise.” – W.E.B. Du Bois}
• _{“A strong woman stands firm in her beliefs, even when the world tries to silence her.” – Michelle Obama}

_{2. Women and Leadership}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Women are the backbone of any progressive nation.” – Indira Gandhi}
• _{“No country can progress without giving women equal opportunities in leadership.” – A.P.J. Abdul Kalam}
• _{“A woman leader is not just a leader for women but a leader for society.” – Priyanka Gandhi}
• _{“Women don’t need reservations; they need equal opportunities.” – Smriti Irani}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“The world needs strong women—women who will lift and build others.” – Amy Tenney}
• _{“If you want something said, ask a man; if you want something done, ask a woman.” – Margaret Thatcher}
• _{“Leadership is about making others better as a result of your presence and making sure that impact lasts in your absence.” – Sheryl Sandberg}
• _{“You can tell who the strong women are. They are the ones you see building each other up.” – Unknown}

_{3. Women and Economic Empowerment}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Empowering women economically is the key to a nation’s prosperity.” – Nirmala Sitharaman}
• _{“A woman’s self-reliance is the foundation of her dignity.” – P.V. Sindhu}
• _{“Financial independence gives a woman the power to make choices.” – Sudha Murty}
• _{“Women’s empowerment is about making them financially independent and socially confident.” – Nita Ambani}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“There is no tool for development more effective than the empowerment of women.” – Kofi Annan}
• _{“When women earn, they invest 90% back into their families and communities.” – World Bank Report}
• _{“Women’s economic empowerment is not just good for women—it’s good for the world.” – Melinda Gates}
• _{“Women should not be just consumers of wealth; they should be creators of wealth.” – Christine Lagarde}

_{4. Women and Justice}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Justice for women is not just a legal necessity but a moral obligation.” – B.R. Ambedkar}
• _{“A society that fails to protect its women is a society doomed to fail.” – Mahatma Gandhi}
• _{“The real test of progress is how we treat our women.” – Dr. Rajendra Prasad}
• _{“Crime against women is a crime against the entire humanity.” – Kiran Bedi}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.” – Benjamin Franklin}
• _{“A woman’s right to equality is not negotiable.” – Hillary Clinton}
• _{“The test of civilization is in the way it treats its women.” – Charles Fourier}
• _{“Equality is not just about words but about actions that make a difference.” – Ruth Bader Ginsburg}

_{5. Women in Science, Technology, and Innovation}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Women in STEM are not just breaking barriers, they are building futures.” – Tessy Thomas (Missile Woman of India)}
• _{“The power of a nation lies in its ability to harness the potential of its women in science and technology.” – Kalpana Chawla}
• _{“Women are capable of achieving great heights in science, provided they are given the right opportunities.” – Dr. Janaki Ammal}
• _{“Let no girl think that science is beyond her reach.” – Dr. Anandibai Joshi}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“We need women in science, technology, engineering, and math. Without them, we won’t be able to solve the world’s biggest problems.” – Sheryl Sandberg}
• _{“Science needs women just as much as women need science.” – Marie Curie}
• _{“Girls can do anything boys can do, and more.” – Katherine Johnson}
• _{“Don’t let anyone rob you of your imagination, your creativity, or your curiosity.” – Mae Jemison}

_{6. Women and Education}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“A girl’s education is a guarantee of a better future for the nation.” – Dr. Radhakrishnan}
• _{“When you educate a girl, you change a generation.” – Jyotirao Phule}
• _{“The right to education is the most powerful tool for women’s empowerment.” – Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam}
• _{“Education is a woman’s best armor against inequality.” – Savitribai Phule}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” – Nelson Mandela}
• _{“There is no limit to what a woman can achieve when she is educated.” – Malala Yousafzai}
• _{“An educated woman has the power to educate an entire society.” – Michelle Obama}
• _{“The seeds of change are in education, and women hold the key.” – Oprah Winfrey}

_{7. Women’s Role in Peace and Security}

_{Indian Thinkers}

• _{“Peace and security in any society depend on the safety and empowerment of women.” – Indira Gandhi}
• _{“A nation that respects women will always be a prosperous and peaceful nation.” – Mahatma Gandhi}
• _{“Women’s role in conflict resolution is as important as men’s.” – Kiran Bedi}
• _{“The hands that nurture also have the power to protect.” – Laxmi Agarwal}

_{Western Thinkers}

• _{“Women’s participation in peace-building leads to more durable solutions.” – Angelina Jolie}
• _{“There is no sustainable peace without women’s leadership.” – UN Women}
• _{“Women bring different perspectives to conflict resolution, which are crucial for lasting peace.” – Madeleine Albright}
• _{“A strong nation is one where women feel safe and empowered.” – Ban Ki-moon}

 

 

Introduction

The foundation of a democratic society lies in its diversity. To ensure that discrimination based on religion, gender, caste, language, color, or location does not prevail and that social harmony and order are maintained, it is essential to have a strong state above society. This state must be represented by a government that gives it a concrete form.

A government should continuously adhere to democratic processes, govern according to constitutional provisions, and maintain legitimacy through ongoing public approval. Therefore, it is necessary that elections are held at regular intervals to elect a government for a fixed term.

Periodic elections serve as the backbone of a democratic government, allowing the public to actively participate in governance. They also provide political parties with the opportunity to improve their performance in line with public aspirations.

Since India's democratic governance system is a synthesis of the parliamentary model and the federal system based on the Canadian model, elections for legislatures are held at both the union and state levels.

During India's first general elections, elections for both Parliament and State Assemblies were held simultaneously. However, over time, the central government misused the position of state governors, either dissolving state assemblies prematurely or imposing President's Rule.

Simultaneously, the coalition politics that emerged in the late 1970s led to unstable governments due to fragmented Lok Sabha formations, increasing the frequency of general elections. These two factors resulted in frequent legislative elections, ending the practice of simultaneous elections in 1968. Today, elections take place in different states almost every year.

This continuous electoral process has highlighted the need for changes in India's electoral framework and structure. The primary argument supporting this change is that the frequent enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct disrupts efficient governance. Additionally, the recurring nature of elections imposes a significant financial burden on administrative and security systems, which is not in the "national interest."

Furthermore, frequent elections also impact economic development and social stability. These reasons have fueled support for the "One Nation, One Election" concept, advocating for simultaneous elections for state legislatures and the Lok Sabha.

Elections form the foundation of India's democracy. Since the "One Nation, One Election" concept is directly linked to the election system in India, its study and analysis are of great importance.

As a concept, it is relatively new in the Indian context, necessitating academic exploration of its various aspects. Elections are essential for the orderly functioning of a diverse and democratic country like India.

Regular elections at the central, state, and local levels strengthen India's democratic framework and enhance political efficiency. Therefore, it is crucial to analyze the feasibility of holding simultaneous elections at both central and state levels.

India's democratic framework has thrived due to its dynamic electoral process, enabling citizens to actively shape governance at all levels. Since independence, over 400 Lok Sabha and state assembly elections have demonstrated the commitment of the Election Commission of India to fairness and transparency. However, the fragmented and frequent nature of these elections has sparked discussions about the need for a more efficient system, reviving interest in the "One Nation, One Election" concept.

This idea, also known as simultaneous elections, proposes conducting elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies at the same time. Voters would cast their ballots for both levels of government on a single day in their respective constituencies, although elections could still be conducted in multiple phases nationwide. The objective of synchronizing election timelines is to address administrative challenges, reduce election-related expenses, and minimize governance disruptions caused by frequent elections.

A high-level committee report on simultaneous elections was released in 2024, providing a comprehensive framework for implementing this approach. The report was accepted by the Union Cabinet on September 18, 2024, marking a significant step in electoral reform. Supporters of this system argue that it could enhance administrative efficiency, reduce election expenses, and promote policy continuity. Given India's aspirations for streamlined governance and adaptable democratic processes, the "One Nation, One Election" concept has emerged as a major reform requiring thorough deliberation and consensus.

Historical Background

The concept of simultaneous elections is not new to India. From 1951 to 1967, elections for the Lok Sabha and all state assemblies were conducted simultaneously. The first general elections in 1951-52 followed this practice, which continued for three more elections in 1957, 1962, and 1967.

However, the early dissolution of certain state assemblies in 1968 and 1969 disrupted this practice. The fourth Lok Sabha was also prematurely dissolved in 1970, leading to fresh elections in 1971. While the first three Lok Sabhas completed their five-year terms, the fifth Lok Sabha’s tenure was extended until 1977 due to the declaration of an emergency under Article 352. Since then, only the eighth, tenth, fourteenth, and fifteenth Lok Sabhas have completed full terms, whereas others, including the sixth, seventh, ninth, eleventh, twelfth, and thirteenth Lok Sabhas, were dissolved prematurely.

State assemblies have faced similar challenges in recent years, with frequent early dissolutions and tenure extensions. These disruptions have significantly affected the cycle of simultaneous elections, leading to the fragmented electoral schedule observed today.

 

High-Level Committee on Simultaneous Elections

On September 2, 2023, the Indian government formed a high-level committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind to assess the feasibility of conducting simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. The committee sought public and political responses on the matter and consulted experts to evaluate the potential benefits and challenges of this electoral reform. The report provides a comprehensive overview of the committee's findings, its recommendations for constitutional amendments, and the expected impact of simultaneous elections on governance, resources, and public sentiment.

Key Findings:

• Public Opinion: The committee received over 21,500 responses, with 80% supporting simultaneous elections. Feedback came from all regions of India, including Lakshadweep, Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Nagaland, and Dadra and Nagar Haveli. The highest number of responses came from Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Kerala, West Bengal, Gujarat, and Uttar Pradesh.
• Political Parties’ Views: Out of 47 political parties, 32 supported simultaneous elections, citing benefits such as efficient resource utilization and social harmony. However, 15 parties raised concerns about potential anti-democratic effects and the marginalization of regional parties.
• Expert Consultation: Former Chief Justices of India, former Election Commissioners, and legal experts overwhelmingly supported the idea, highlighting the wastage of resources and socio-economic disruptions caused by frequent elections.
• Economic Impact: Business organizations such as CII, FICCI, and ASSOCHAM supported the proposal, emphasizing its positive impact on economic stability by reducing election-related costs and disruptions.
• Legal and Constitutional Analysis: The committee recommended amendments to Articles 82A and 324A of the Indian Constitution to facilitate simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha, state assemblies, and local bodies.
• Implementation Approach: The committee proposed a two-phase implementation strategy:
  • Phase 1: Conduct simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies.
  • Phase 2: Hold municipal and panchayat elections within 100 days of the Lok Sabha and assembly elections.

Rationale for Simultaneous Elections

1. Continuity in Governance: The current electoral cycle often distracts political leaders from governance, as they focus on upcoming elections. Simultaneous elections would allow governments to concentrate on policy implementation and development initiatives.
2. Reduced Policy Delays: The Model Code of Conduct disrupts administrative activities and welfare initiatives. Simultaneous elections would minimize such disruptions, ensuring timely policy execution.
3. Efficient Resource Utilization: Election-related administrative tasks divert officials from their primary responsibilities. A synchronized election cycle would reduce the frequency of such diversions.
4. Relevance of Regional Parties: Contrary to concerns, simultaneous elections would maintain the significance of regional parties by allowing them to focus on local issues without national election influences.
5. Financial Efficiency: Reducing the number of election cycles would significantly cut down election-related expenses, allowing better fiscal management and promoting investor confidence.

Disadvantages of Conducting Simultaneous Elections

The idea of "One Nation, One Election" has several advantages, but it also comes with significant challenges and potential drawbacks. Here are some key concerns associated with implementing simultaneous elections in India:

1. Impact on Federalism: India follows a federal structure where both the central and state governments function independently. If elections for both Lok Sabha and state assemblies are held together, it may undermine the autonomy of state governments and centralize power excessively.

2. Reduced Focus on Regional Issues: When national and state elections are held simultaneously, national parties and issues tend to dominate the discourse. This could marginalize regional parties and local issues, as voters may be more inclined to focus on broader national concerns rather than state-specific problems.

3. Impact on Democratic Process: Frequent elections ensure continuous engagement between political parties and the public. They provide an opportunity for citizens to hold the government accountable at regular intervals. If elections are held only once in five years, public grievances may not receive timely attention.

4. Complexity in Case of Government Collapse: If a state government or the central government falls before completing its tenure, it creates uncertainty. Would the state be placed under President’s Rule until the next synchronized election? Holding fresh elections in between would defeat the purpose of simultaneous elections.

5. Threat to Political Diversity: Large national parties, with greater financial and organizational resources, could gain a significant advantage in simultaneous elections. This may weaken smaller regional parties and impact India’s multi-party democracy, reducing political diversity.

6. Influence on Voter Choice: Currently, voters can make different choices in national and state elections based on distinct leadership and policies. However, when elections are held simultaneously, voters may be inclined to vote for the same party at both levels, potentially reducing political checks and balances.

7. Logistical and Administrative Challenges

• Conducting elections across the entire country simultaneously requires massive security arrangements and administrative coordination.
• A large number of EVMs (Electronic Voting Machines) and VVPATs would be needed, which may pose logistical difficulties.
• Managing electoral staff and ensuring smooth polling operations nationwide would be a monumental task.

8. Impact on Development Activities

• Governments often announce new policies and welfare schemes keeping elections in mind. If elections occur only once every five years, governments might not be as responsive to public demands between election cycles.
• Frequent elections force governments to remain accountable and sensitive to public needs.

9. Constitutional Amendments Required: Implementing "One Nation, One Election" would require several constitutional changes, including:

• Amendments to Articles 83 and 172, which define the tenure of Lok Sabha and State Assemblies.
• Changes to Article 356, which deals with President’s Rule in states and could affect governance if elections are delayed.

Conclusion

The high-level committee, led by former President Ram Nath Kovind, has laid the foundation for a transformative shift in India's electoral process. By aligning Lok Sabha and state assembly election cycles, the proposed reforms aim to address longstanding challenges related to governance disruptions and resource wastage. With broad public and political support, the "One Nation, One Election" concept is poised to streamline India's democratic processes and enhance administrative efficiency.

Introduction

India and the United States share a multifaceted and strategic partnership, rooted in shared democratic values, economic interests, and security priorities. Over the decades, this relationship has evolved from a hesitant engagement during the Cold War era to a comprehensive global partnership in the 21st century.

In 2025, India-US relations are marked by robust cooperation across diverse sectors, including defence, trade, technology, and cultural exchange. The strategic partnership is underpinned by common goals of promoting regional stability, countering terrorism, and fostering economic growth.

Both nations collaborate extensively in emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, space exploration, and cyber security, positioning themselves as leaders in global innovation. Additionally, defence ties have deepened through joint military exercises, defence procurement, and strategic dialogues, particularly in the Indo-Pacific region.

Economic engagement remains a cornerstone of bilateral relations, with the U.S. being one of India's largest trading partners. Ongoing negotiations for a Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA) reflect the commitment to expanding trade and investment opportunities. However, challenges such as trade imbalances, political dynamics, and differing climate change priorities continue to shape diplomatic engagements.

Amidst a rapidly changing global geopolitical landscape, the India-US partnership stands as a pillar of stability and progress. As both nations navigate complex regional and global challenges, their collaboration is pivotal in shaping a secure, prosperous, and sustainable future.

High-Level Exchanges

• Regular dialogue between the Leaders is an important element of the expanding bilateral ties. The outcomes of these visits have been instrumental in strengthening the multifaceted bilateral ties.
• There is regular high-level interaction with Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi and President Biden. The respective leaders had several bilateral meetings and met on the sidelines of multilateral events. Prime Minister also participated in virtual Summits convened by President Biden including Quad, I2U2 (India, Israel, USA and UAE), Summit for Democracy and other events.
• PM Modi made his first State Visit to US from 21-23 June 2023 at the invitation of President Biden. In addition to a bilateral meeting with President Biden, he addressed a Joint Meeting of US’ Congress and interacted with business and thought leaders. PM Modi had visited the US in September 2021 for the first in-person Quad Leaders’ Summit on 24 September 2021 and had a bilateral meeting with President Biden. 
• President Biden visited New Delhi from 8-10 September 2023 to attend G-20 Leaders’ Summit. President Biden and PM Modi had a bilateral meeting and co-hosted a group of G20 leaders to accelerate investments in high-quality infrastructure projects and development of economic corridors through the India Middle East Europe Economic Connectivity Corridor and the Partnership for Global Infrastructure and Investment (PGI).

Recent Visits from U.S.

• U.S. National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan visited India on January 5-6, 2025, for discussions with his Indian counterpart, Ajit Doval, and other senior officials. The meetings focused on a wide range of bilateral, regional, and global issues, aiming to finalize ongoing initiatives before the U.S. administration transition. During his visit, Sullivan delivered a significant foreign policy speech at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Delhi, highlighting the importance of U.S.-India relations in the evolving geopolitical landscape.
• NSA Jake Sullivan visited in June 2024 for Second iCET Summit.
• US Trade Representative Ambassador Katherine Tai for 14th India-US Trade Policy Forum in January 2024.
• Senior Advisor to the President for International Climate Policy John Podesta in August 2024.
• Deputy Secretary of State for Management and Resources Richard Verma visited India in February 2024 and again in August 2024.

Recent Visits to US:

• On February 13, 2025, President Donald J. Trump hosted Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi for an official working visit in Washington, D.C. The leaders discussed enhancing defense cooperation, with President Trump announcing plans to increase military sales to India, including the potential provision of F-35 fighter jets. Additionally, agreements were made to boost India's imports of U.S. oil and gas, aiming to reduce the trade deficit between the two countries.
• From December 24 to 29, 2024, India's External Affairs Minister, S. Jaishankar, visited the United States. During this period, he engaged with officials from both the outgoing Biden administration and the incoming Trump administration. The discussions aimed to ensure a smooth diplomatic transition and to lay the groundwork for continued collaboration on key issues such as defence, trade, and technology.
• EAM and Secretary Blinken met in Tokyo on the side-lines of Quad Foreign Ministers’ Meeting in July 2024. Earlier, EAM and Secretary Blinken attended the Munich Security Conference in February 2024. EAM met Secretary Blinken in Cambodia on sidelines of EAS in November 2022, August 2022, on side-lines of G20 FMM in Bali in July 2022, and on side-lines of G7 Summit in June 2022.
• Raksha Mantri visited the US in August 2024 and earlier in April 2022 for 4th 2+2 Ministerial Meeting.
• Foreign Secretary visited Washington DC from 9-12 April 2024 and held meetings at White House, State Department, Department of Commerce, Department of Defense. He also interacted with prominent think tanks and the business community. He had earlier visited Washington DC in June 2023 for the inaugural Strategic Trade Dialogue and other bilateral interactions.
• Principal Scientific Advisor (PSA) Shri Ajay Sood visited Washington DC and California in August 2024 for second bilateral meeting of Quantum Coordination Mechanism and related lab and industry visits.

Parliamentary Exchanges

                India-US relations enjoy strong bipartisan support in the US Congress. The India Caucus in the US Congress comprising the Senate India Caucus and the House Caucus on India and Indian Americans is one of the largest single country Caucus in the US Congress with more than 100 members.

Defence Cooperation

• India-US defence cooperation is based on “New Framework for India-US Defence Cooperation”, which was renewed for ten years in 2015. In 2016, the defence relationship was designated as a Major Defence Partnership (MDP). On 30 July 2018, India was moved into the Tier-1 of the US Department of Commerce’s Strategic Trade Authorization license exception.
• Defence cooperation is multifaceted and includes regular institutionalized bilateral dialogue, military exercises, and defence procurements. At the apex of dialogue mechanisms is the 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue co-chaired by the Minister of External Affairs and Minister of Defence and the US Secretary of State and Secretary of Defense. This dialogue provides guidance on political, military and strategic issues. The fifth 2 + 2 Ministerial Dialogue took place in November 2023 in New Delhi. RM visited the US in August 2024. During the visit, RM met with Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin and NSA Jake Sullivan. He interacted with US’ defense industry and Indian community. Security of Supply Arrangement (SoSA) and MoA regarding Assignment of Liaison Officers were signed during the visit. India shall accordingly deploy an LO to US Special Operations Command (US SOCOM) in Tampa, Florida.
• The Defense Policy Group (DPG) headed by the Defence Secretary and Under Secretary of Defense (Policy) provides a platform for a comprehensive review of defense dialogues/mechanisms. The 17th DPG was held in Washington D.C. in May 2023. Defence procurement from the US are growing and amount to more than US$20 billion. Major USorigin platforms in use include C-130J, C-17, Apache, Chinook, MH60R helicopters, and

P8I. Other bilateral dialogue mechanisms are the Defense Production and Procurement Group (DPPG), Joint Technology Group (JTG), bilateral Maritime Security Dialogue, Industrial Security Summit and the Defence Trade and Technology Initiative.

• Since 2022, three US’ Maritime Sealift Command ships have visited Indian Shipyards for repair and allied services based on commercial contracts.
• Important defence agreements which provide the framework for interaction and cooperation are: Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (2016); Communications Compatibility and Security Agreement (2018); Industrial Security Agreement (2019); and Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement (2020) and Memorandum of Intent for Defense Innovation Cooperation (2018).
• The India-US Defence Industrial Cooperation Roadmap which concluded in May 2023, seeks to fast-track technology cooperation and co-production in areas of mutual interest. The India-US Defense Acceleration Ecosystem (INDUS X) – a network of universities, incubators, corporates, think tanks, and private investment stakeholders was launched in June 2023. The second INDUS X Summit was held in New Delhi in February 2024.
• Military to Military exchanges take place through high-level visits, Exercises, Training Courses, and regular service-specific bilateral mechanisms. India has the largest number of military exercises with USA, which are growing in scale and complexity. Important bilateral exercises include Yudh Abhyas (Army), Vajra Prahar (Special Forces), Malabar (Navy), Cope India (Air Force), and Tiger Triumph (tri-services). Red Flag, RIMPAC, CUTLASS Express, Sea Dragon, Milan are some of the Multilateral Exercises in which the two countries participate. INS Satpura was the first Indian naval ship to visit US mainland when it came to San Diego in August 2022 as a part of Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav. India joined the multilateral Combined Maritime Force (CMF) based in Bahrain, as an Associate Partner in April 2022. Counter Terrorism Cooperation
• Cooperation in counterterrorism is one of the pillars of the bilateral partnership featuring information exchange, capacity building, operational cooperation and regular dialogue through the India-U.S. Joint Working Group on Counterterrorism. In 2017, both sides initiated a dialogue on domestic and international terrorist designations listing proposals. The last JWG on CT and Designations Dialogue was in Washington DC on 5 March 2024.
• In February 2025, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Washington, marking a significant step in reinforcing defence ties between the two nations. Both countries have committed to deepening their partnership, with Modi emphasizing a collaborative vision: "When America and India work together, when it's MAGA plus MIGA, it becomes mega—a mega partnership for prosperity."

 

Security Cooperation

• The Homeland Security Dialogue (HSD) at the Home Minister/Secretary of Department of Homeland Security level was established in 2010. There are five joint subgroups under HSD dealing with Border and Global Supply Chain Security, Law Enforcement Engagements and Cooperation, Capacity Building, and Aviation Security. US’
• Senior Official Performing the Duties of the Deputy Secretary Kristie Canegallo and India’s Home Secretary Ajay Bhalla co-chaired the US-India Homeland Security Dialogue in February 2024 in New Delhi. India also participated in the U.S. led Counter Ransomware Initiative meeting in Washington D.C. in November 2023.

Counter-Narcotics Cooperation

• The fourth bilateral Counter Narcotics Working Group (CNWG) meeting was held in Washington D.C. in July 2023. India also joined the US-led Global Coalition on Synthetic Drugs.

Cyber Security Cooperation

• The India-US Cyber Framework signed in September 2016. India-US Cyber Dialogue was held in Washington D.C. in September 2022, led by respective DNSAs. India also participated in the US led Counter Ransomware Initiative meeting in Washington D.C. in November 2022.
• US is the largest trading partner of India with over all bilateral trade in goods and services of $190.1 billion for calendar year 2023. (Source: US Census data)
• During FY 2023-24, US was the third largest source of FDI into India with inflows of USD 4.99 billion accounting for almost 9% of total FDI equity inflows. Many Indian companies are investing in the US and adding value. According to a CII study released in April 2023,163 Indian companies invested over $40 billion in the US and created over 425,000 direct jobs.
•  An Investment Incentive Agreement between our Ministry of Finance and U.S. International Development Finance Cooperation [DFC] was signed in 2022 to enable equity investment, co-insurance, grants, feasibility studies, and technical assistance. As of January 2024, DFC’s India portfolio stood at close to 4.0 billion across 100+ projects.

Dialogue Mechanisms:

• India-US Trade Policy Forum (TPF): Established in 2005, TPF discusses market access and trade related matters. The 14th TPF was held in New Delhi, India, on January 12, 2024, led by CIM and USTR.
• India-US Commercial Dialogue: Focuses on cooperation in standards, ease of doing business, travel & tourism, and other important issues of commercial significance. It is co-chaired by CIM and the U.S. Secretary of Commerce. The fifth Commercial Dialogue was held in New Delhi on 10 March 2023.
• India-US CEO Forum: Established in 2005, the Forum meets on sidelines of the Commercial Dialogue and submits recommendations to the Commercial dialogue. The CEO forum met on March 10, 2023 in New Delhi. On November 30, 2023, the Indian Minister of Commerce and Industry Shri Piyush Goyal and the US Secretary of Commerce Ms. Gina Raimondo convened a virtual review of the India US CEO forum as a follow-up to the March 2023 meeting.
• Information and Communications Technology: A Joint Working Group on ICT was established in 2005 to bring together government and industry from both sides to discuss cooperation in electronics & IT sector. The last meeting was in May 2023 in Washington DC.
• India – US Economic and Financial Partnership Dialogue (EFP): Led by our finance minister and the US Secretary of the Treasury, the 9th ministerial EFP Dialogue was held in November 2022 in New Delhi. 11th Financial and Regulatory Dialogue was held in March 2023, in Gandhinagar.
• Indo-Pacific Economic Framework [IPEF]: India joined the launch of the IPEF in May 2022 along with 13 Partner countries. India joined three of the four Pillars of IPEF, related to supply chains (2), tax and anti-corruption (4) and clean energy (3).  Text of Pillar 2 ‘Supply chain resilience’ was finalized in May 2023 which has come into force since February 2024. IPEF Ministerial Meetings this year, were held in March 2024 and June 2024. Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity (IPEF) Clean Economy Investor Forum (“Investor Forum”) was held on 6 June 2024 at the Sands Expo and Convention Centre, Singapore.

Strategic Energy Partnership/ Climate & Clean Energy Agenda 2030.

India and US have a strong bilateral partnership in energy sector. In April 2021, an India-US Climate and Clean Energy Agenda 2030 Partnership was launched, with two tracks i.e. Strategic Clean Energy Partnership (SCEP); and Climate Action and Finance Mobilization Dialogue (CAFMD). The SCEP has five pillars:

1) Power & Energy Efficiency,

2) Renewable Energy,

3) Responsible Oil & Gas,

4) Sustainable Growth, and

5) Emerging

• An Energy Storage Task Force supports integration of renewable energy needed to support the clean energy transition. The last SCEP Ministerial meeting led by US Energy Secretary and Minister of Petroleum and Natural Gas was held in Delhi, India in July 2023.
• Hydrocarbon trade was US$ 13.6 billion in FY 2023-24.
• The US joined the International Solar Alliance in 2021 and ratified the ISA Agreement in 2022. US is also a Member of the Coalition for Disaster Relief Infrastructure (CDRI). India participates in the Major Economies Forum hosted annually by the US with focus on climate actions.
• In August 2023 India and the US launched US-India Renewable Energy Technology Action Platform (RETAP), to enable lab-to-lab collaboration, pilot projects, and testing of innovative technologies and capacitive development.
• The two countries agreed to a payment security mechanism financed through both public and private funds for providing financial guarantee to e-Bus manufacturers/operators in India.
• To lower the cost of capital and accelerate the deployment of greenfield renewable energy, battery storage and emerging green technology projects in India, in September 2023. Towards this end, India’s National Investment and Infrastructure Fund and the U.S. Development Finance Corporation exchanged letters of interest to each provide up to US$500 million to anchor a renewable infrastructure investment fund. The terms and conditions of the fund are under discussion.

S&T and Space Cooperation

• The Science and Technology Cooperation Agreement signed in October 2005, was renewed for 10 years in September 2019. The Indo-US Science and Technology Forum (IUSSTF) promote cooperation in S&T and Innovation. U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF) and India’s DST, MeiTY and DBT signed three different Implementation Arrangements to support research collaboration in AI, advanced communication networks, quantum science, Internet of Things, Interdisciplinary Cyber Physical System, biotechnology manufacturing, bio safety and biosecurity etc.
•  India and the US have a long history of cooperation in the civil space arena in Earth Observation, Satellite Navigation, Space Science and Exploration. Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) has robust civilian space cooperation with the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA); National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA); US Geological Survey (USGS) and academic institutions. India-US have setup a dialogue mechanism “Civil Space Joint Working Group (CSJWG)” for continuous evaluation and fostering the Space Cooperation. The last meeting of CSJWG was held in Washington D.C. in January 2023, co-chaired by Scientific Secretary, ISRO Associate Administrator of NASA and Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary, Department of State.
• ISRO and NASA are developing a microwave remote sensing satellite for Earth observation, NASA-ISRO Synthetic Aperture Radar (NISAR). NASA/JPL will contribute L-band Radar, while ISRO will contribute S-band Radar. S-band SAR from SAC/ISRO  Ahmedabad was delivered to NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) in May 2021. An integrated payload was sent to URSC/ISRO Bangalore for integration with Satellite. Currently, the satellite is under the final stage of integration and testing and expected to be launched from Shriharikota, India later in 2024. The launch of Indian satellite GSAT20 onboard the US’ launch vehicle Falcon-9 is scheduled to take place from Florida, US in September 2024.
• ISRO availed NASA/JPL’s Deep Space Network Antenna support Chandrayaan-2 mission, and Chandrayaan-3 satellite missions. ISRO and NASA successfully implemented Professional Scientific Personnel Exchange Programme (PESEP) in earth observation applications under the framework signed in April 2017. During the last CSJWG discussion in January 2023, ISRO and NASA agreed to expand the scope for including space science, Earth science, and human spaceflight under PESEP.
• In January 2024, ISRO and NASA signed a Joint Statement of Intent to deepen their partnership in space exploration and mount a joint effort to the International Space Station. ISRO and NASA signed an IA for Strategic framework for cooperation in human spaceflight in March 2024.
•  Principal Scientific Advisor (PSA) Shri Ajay Sood visited Washington DC and California in August 2024 for the second bilateral meeting of Quantum Coordination Mechanism and related lab and industry visits.
• NASA Administrator Senator Bill Nelson visited the India during November-December 2023. He had meetings with MOS PMO and Dy. NSA in New Delhi. He visited ISRO HQ and had a meeting with Chairman ISRO/ Secretary DOS.
• Initiative for Critical and Emerging Technology [iCET] was launched by the National Security Advisors in Washington, DC on 31 January 2023 to facilitate strategic technology collaborations in critical and emerging technologies, co-development, and coproduction, connect the respective innovation ecosystems especially in AI, quantum, telecom, space, biotech, semiconductors, emerging defence technologies and biotech. The second iCET meeting was held in New Delhi on 13-14 June 2023. An intersessional review of iCET was held in New Delhi on December 4, 2023, between the US Principal Deputy National Security Advisor Jon Finer and the Indian Deputy National Security Advisor Vikram Misri. The second iCET Summit, chaired by the two NSAs, was held in New Delhi on 17 July 2024.

Health Cooperation

• There is a longstanding research collaboration in the health sector to develop new therapeutics and diagnostics. Under the Bilateral Vaccine Action Program (VAP), a ROTAVAC® vaccine to counter diarrhoea in children was developed by an Indian company at an affordable cost. The 34th JWG of VAP was held in Washington DC in 2022.
• There are more than 200 active collaborations between US National Institutes of Health network of labs and leading research agencies, to deliver affordable health-care solutions.  India supplies about 40% of generic formulations marketed in US. Indian pharma companies have manufacturing units in about 14 locations in US. Indian companies, known for quality generic medicines have the largest US Food and Drug Administration compliant pharmaceutical plants. Indian Institutions are collaborating to promote Ayurveda.
• The India-US Health Dialogue is led by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of India and US Department of Health and Human Services. In 2021, the fourth Dialogue was held in New Delhi. The fifth dialogue was held in Washington DC during 9-12 Oct 2023 which discussed several areas of cooperation including pandemic preparedness, health safety and security, digital health, vaccine development, maternal and child health, traditional medicines, food and drug administrations, etc.
• India participated in the US-led Global Action Plan (GAP) launched in February 2022 to bridge policy gaps and end the COVID.
• Under the US initiative, Cancer Moonshot, launched in June 2023, India’s DBT and US National Cancer Institute facilitate public and private sector’s commitments to reduce the burden of cancer in India. First meeting of the India- US Cancer Dialogue under the Cancer Moonshot programme was held on 5-6 August 2024 in New Delhi.  

Education & Cultural Cooperation

• Education partnership is an important pillar of India-US ties with strong linkages and history of higher education collaborations. Under the Fulbright-Nehru Bi-National Program, both countries support Fulbright-Nehru scholarships and grants to US and Indian scholars, professionals, and students. The Global Initiative of Academic Networks (GIAN) was launched by India in 2015 to facilitate visits by 1000 US teachers annually to teach in India. GIAN has been extended to other countries also.
• The India-US Working Group on Education and Skill Development (WGESD) was launched in May 2023 to focus on skilling and vocational education, certification and recognition, matchmaking between higher educational institutions and engaging with private sector. Subcommittees on Linkages in higher education, Leveraging Private Sector, Skilling and Vocational Training, and Certification and Recognition were launched in February 2024.
• The US is one of the most favoured destinations of Indian students for higher education. As of May 2024, there are about 3,51,000 Indian students, mostly in graduate (masters) programs in STEM fields. As per the US State Department’s website, Indian students in the US contribute about $8 billion annually to the US economy.
• In September 2023, the Council of Indian Institutes of Technology (IIT Council), and the Association of American Universities (AAU) signed an MOU to establish India-US Global Challenges Institute which will bring together leading research and higher education institutions for S&T collaboration in sustainable energy and agriculture, health and pandemic preparedness, semiconductor technology and manufacturing, advanced materials, telecommunications, artificial intelligence, and quantum science.
• The academic collaboration has been multifaceted, encompassing joint research, faculty and student exchange programs, joint degree programs, and other activities. There are growing multi-institutional collaborative education partnerships in critical and emerging technologies. IIT Bombay joined the Chicago Quantum Exchange as an international partner. Several IITs have strong ongoing academic research partnerships with universities in the US.
• Cultural cooperation is rich and manifests in diverse ways. There are India-focused educational programs in universities and educational institutions. Indian Embassy and Consulates organize various cultural events to showcase diverse facets of Indian culture. Artists and technical experts from both countries undergo training in each other’s institutions. Programs highlighting Indian cultural heritage, Indian festivals, and initiatives such as International Day of Yoga, World Hindi Diwas, Gandhi Jayanti, Ayurveda day are organized from time to time with participation of Indian diaspora and friends of India. Indian Diaspora cultural organizations are engaged in actively promoting Indian culture especially in younger generation.
• India and the US signed the first ever 'Cultural Property Agreement' in July 2024 in New Delhi to prevent and curb the illicit trafficking of antiquities.

Economic and Trade Cooperation

The economic partnership has seen notable developments. U.S. pharmaceutical company Amgen announced a $200 million investment in a new technology center in Hyderabad, India, focusing on leveraging AI and data science for drug development. This initiative aims to employ around 2,000 people by the end of the year, exemplifying the growing technological collaboration between the two countries.

Challenges and Controversies in India-USA Relations (2025)

Despite the positive trajectory, challenges persist. A recent political controversy arose when Elon Musk claimed that the U.S. had cancelled a $21 million grant intended to support voter turnout in India. However, records indicate no such funds were allocated to India; instead, the money was directed towards political engagement in Bangladesh. This misinformation has fueled suspicions and political debates in both countries.

1. Political Challenges and Misinformation

• Misinformation Incident Involving Elon Musk:
  In early 2025, a political controversy arose when Elon Musk alleged that the U.S. cancelled a $21 million grant meant to support voter turnout in India. However, official records showed that the funds were actually allocated to political engagement in Bangladesh, not India.
  • Impact: This misinformation fuelled political debates and suspicions, impacting diplomatic trust and creating political narratives that could strain bilateral ties.
  • Implication: The incident underscores the growing challenge of misinformation in international relations, necessitating transparent communication and proactive diplomacy.
     
• Domestic Political Dynamics:
  Both nations face complex domestic political landscapes that influence foreign policy decisions. In the U.S., partisan politics can impact trade and defence agreements, while in India, domestic electoral considerations may influence foreign policy stances.
  • Example: Any perceived foreign interference or influence in domestic politics can trigger nationalist sentiments, complicating diplomatic negotiations.

2. Economic and Trade Disputes

• Trade Imbalances and Protectionism:
  Despite ongoing negotiations for a Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA), trade imbalances and protectionist policies remain points of contention.
  • Issue: The U.S. has expressed concerns over India's high tariffs on American goods, while India seeks greater access to the U.S. market for its technology and pharmaceutical products.
  • Negotiation Hurdles: Disagreements on intellectual property rights, data localization laws, and digital trade regulations continue to pose challenges.
• Impact of Global Economic Trends:
  Global economic uncertainties, including supply chain disruptions and currency fluctuations, influence bilateral trade dynamics. Additionally, the U.S.-China trade tensions indirectly impact India's trade relations with the U.S., as both countries navigate the shifting global trade landscape.

3. Defense and Strategic Concerns

• Geopolitical Tensions in the Indo-Pacific:
  The strategic cooperation between India and the U.S. is heavily influenced by Indo-Pacific security dynamics, particularly concerning China's assertive actions in the South China Sea.
  • Challenge: Balancing strategic interests while avoiding direct confrontation with China is a delicate diplomatic manoeuvre for both nations.
  • Implication: India's participation in the Quad (Quadrilateral Security Dialogue) with the U.S., Japan, and Australia is seen as a strategic counter to China's influence, but it also risks escalating regional tensions.
• Defense Trade and Technology Transfer:
  While defense ties are strengthening, differences over technology transfer agreements and defense procurement policies remain. The U.S. seeks more transparency and protection of intellectual property, while India aims for greater localization and indigenous defense manufacturing.

4. Human Rights and Social Issues

• Human Rights Concerns and Political Criticism:
  The U.S. has periodically raised concerns over human rights issues in India, including religious freedoms, press freedom, and minority rights.
  • Political Sensitivity: Such criticism is often viewed by India as interference in its domestic affairs, leading to diplomatic friction.
  • Example: U.S. lawmakers' comments on India's internal policies have occasionally sparked protests and political backlash in India.
• Visa and Immigration Policies:
  Visa and immigration policies, particularly regarding the H-1B visa program, continue to be a point of contention. Changes in U.S. immigration laws impact Indian professionals in the tech sector, influencing economic and social ties.

5. Environmental and Climate Change Disagreements

• Diverging Climate Change Priorities:
  Despite cooperation on renewable energy and climate technology, India and the U.S. have differing approaches to climate change commitments.
  • Issue: The U.S. emphasizes strict carbon reduction targets, while India advocates for climate justice, emphasizing financial support and technology transfer from developed countries.
  • Diplomatic Challenge: Reconciling these differences is crucial for effective collaboration in global climate forums.

Conclusion

India-U.S. relations in 2025 are characterized by strong strategic and economic partnerships but are also challenged by political dynamics, trade disputes, defence concerns, and social issues. Navigating these challenges requires strategic diplomacy, transparent communication, and mutual respect for each nation’s domestic policies. As the global geopolitical landscape evolves, maintaining a balanced and constructive dialogue will be essential for sustaining this crucial bilateral relationship.

 

By Tarun Ranjan

C.O., Govt. of Bihar

Introduction

The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP), contained in Part IV of the Indian Constitution (Articles 36-51), are guidelines aimed at establishing social justice, economic welfare, and political democracy. Although they are non-justiciable, meaning they cannot be enforced through the judiciary, DPSPs act as moral compasses for the legislative and executive branches to create policies that lead to an equitable society. Bihar, a state known for its rich history and cultural heritage, faces significant socio-economic challenges such as poverty, illiteracy, and underdevelopment. Examining the implementation and impact of DPSPs in Bihar sheds light on the state's efforts to achieve social justice, economic equality, and sustainable development.

Historical Context and Constitutional Basis

The Directive Principles were inspired by the Irish Constitution, reflecting the vision of the Indian freedom struggle's leaders for a welfare state. They aim to promote a just social order and are broadly classified into three categories: Socialistic Principles, Gandhian Principles, and Liberal-Intellectual Principles. Bihar, historically plagued by socio-economic disparities and political instability, has gradually leveraged these principles to enhance governance and social welfare. The state's policies have been significantly shaped by the need to address issues of poverty, caste-based inequality, and lack of infrastructure.

Classification of DPSPs and Their Relevance to Bihar

1. Socialistic Principles

These principles aim to establish a welfare state by reducing wealth disparities and ensuring equitable distribution of resources.

• Article 38: Directs the state to secure a social order for the promotion of the welfare of the people.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • Initiatives like Mukhyamantri Samajik Suraksha Yojana provide financial support to marginalized communities, including Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC).
    • Bihar Public Distribution System (PDS) ensures food security by distributing essential commodities at subsidized rates.
    • Social pension schemes, such as Indira Gandhi National Old Age Pension Scheme, cater to the elderly and differently-abled individuals.
• Article 39: Ensures adequate means of livelihood, equal pay for equal work, and prevents wealth concentration.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) ensures employment and livelihood security, especially in rural areas.
    • Land reforms, including the Bihar Land Reforms Act, aim to redistribute land to the landless, promoting social equity.

2. Gandhian Principles

These principles draw inspiration from Mahatma Gandhi's philosophy, focusing on rural development, social harmony, and self-reliance.

• Article 40: Calls for the organization of village panchayats, empowering local governance.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • The Bihar Panchayati Raj Act institutionalizes decentralized governance, enabling local self-government and community participation.
    • Women’s reservation in Panchayats (50% seats) has promoted gender equality and political empowerment.
• Article 43: Promotes cottage industries and local entrepreneurship.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • Bihar Khadi and Village Industries Board supports traditional industries, providing employment opportunities in rural areas.
    • Startup Bihar Policy encourages youth entrepreneurship, fostering economic growth.
• Article 46: Promotes the educational and economic interests of SCs, STs, and other weaker sections.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • Post Matric Scholarship Scheme and Pre Matric Scholarship for OBC/SC/ST ensure educational opportunities for underprivileged students.
    • Residential schools for SC/ST girls improve access to quality education.

3. Liberal-Intellectual Principles

These principles emphasize individual rights, international peace, scientific progress, and environmental protection.

• Article 44: Advocates for a Uniform Civil Code to ensure social harmony and equality.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • While a Uniform Civil Code is not implemented, Bihar maintains social harmony through inclusive governance and secular policies.
• Article 48A: Directs the state to protect and improve the environment.
  • Implementation in Bihar:
    • Jal-Jeevan-Hariyali Campaign focuses on environmental conservation, water resource management, and afforestation.
    • Clean Ganga Mission in Bihar aims to reduce pollution and restore the ecological health of the Ganges River.

Key Policy Initiatives in Bihar Guided by DPSPs

1. Social Welfare and Poverty Alleviation

• Bihar Rural Livelihoods Project (JEEViKA): Empowers women through Self-Help Groups (SHGs), promoting financial inclusion and entrepreneurship.
• Public Distribution System (PDS): Ensures food security for economically weaker sections, reducing hunger and malnutrition.
• Mukhya Mantri Vidhwa Pension Yojana: Provides financial assistance to widows, supporting economic independence.

2. Education and Skill Development

• Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) and Rashtriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan (RMSA) have increased literacy rates and reduced dropout rates.
• Mukhyamantri Balak/Balika Cycle Yojana encourages girls to attend school, reducing gender disparity in education.
• Kushal Yuva Program: Focuses on skill development and vocational training for youth, enhancing employability.

3. Health and Nutrition

• Mukhyamantri Balika Poshak Yojana provides financial support for girls’ education and health.
• Ayushman Bharat - Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PMJAY) offers health insurance to economically vulnerable families.
• Universal Immunization Program enhances child health and reduces infant mortality.

4. Economic Development and Employment Generation

• Bihar Start-Up Policy encourages innovation and entrepreneurship among the youth.
• MGNREGA provides guaranteed wage employment, reducing migration and promoting rural development.
• Bihar Industrial Investment Promotion Policy aims to attract investment, boosting economic growth and employment.

Challenges in Implementing DPSPs in Bihar

1. Resource Constraints: Limited financial resources and low state revenue hinder effective policy implementation.
2. Political and Bureaucratic Hurdles: Frequent political changes and administrative inefficiencies affect policy continuity.
3. Social and Cultural Barriers: Caste discrimination, gender inequality, and traditional social norms limit progressive reforms.
4. Lack of Infrastructure: Inadequate healthcare, educational, and transport infrastructure impede social welfare programs.

Future Prospects and Recommendations

1. Strengthening Local Governance: Empowering Panchayati Raj Institutions for efficient grassroots implementation.
2. Public-Private Partnerships: Collaborations to enhance infrastructure, healthcare, and educational services.
3. Social Awareness and Community Participation: Mobilizing community support to overcome social barriers and enhance policy outreach.
4. Enhanced Financial Allocation: Increasing budgetary support for social welfare schemes to ensure comprehensive coverage.

Conclusion

The Directive Principles of State Policy provide a blueprint for building a welfare state. In Bihar, they have been instrumental in shaping policies that promote social justice, economic welfare, and environmental sustainability. Although significant progress has been made in poverty alleviation, education, health, and rural development, challenges such as political instability, financial constraints, and social inequalities continue to hinder the full realization of DPSPs.

To overcome these challenges, Bihar needs strategic planning, community involvement, and enhanced governance mechanisms. As Bihar progresses on its development path, DPSPs will continue to guide policymakers, ensuring that growth is inclusive and sustainable, thus fulfilling the vision of a just and equitable society envisioned by the framers of the Indian Constitution.